GET 10% OFF ON YOUR FIRST ORDER. FOR A LIMITED TIME ONLY. Use code: WELCOME on checkout

Are ‘ETF Paper Bitcoins’ Suppressing BTC Prices? Analyst Provides Answers

In a new YouTube video titled “There Is No ETF Paper Bitcoin,” Fred Krueger, an investor at the crypto hedge fund 2718.fund, delved into the growing concerns surrounding US spot Bitcoin Exchange-Traded Funds (ETFs) and their impact on the cryptocurrency’s price. Krueger aimed to dispel the fear, uncertainty, and doubt (FUD) that have been circulating about “paper Bitcoin”—the notion that ETFs might be selling Bitcoin they do not actually possess—and to explain why Bitcoin’s price has not surged as dramatically as some might expect, despite significant ETF purchases.

Krueger began his analysis by acknowledging the prevalent skepticism in the market. “There’s all this paper Bitcoin, and ETFs don’t really have the Bitcoin, and if they were buying all this Bitcoin, how come Bitcoin price is not higher?” he stated, encapsulating the core concerns of many investors.

Historically, the concept of “paper Bitcoin” has been associated with exchanges that sold Bitcoin to customers without actually possessing the underlying assets. Krueger highlighted several high-profile instances where this practice led to significant losses for investors. He cited the case of Mt. Gox.

Another example he provided was QuadrigaCX, a Canadian exchange that collapsed under mysterious circumstances. Founder Gerald Cotten allegedly died in India, taking with him the private keys to the exchange’s cold wallets, effectively locking away customer funds. “A lot of Canadians lost all their Bitcoin on this Quad exchange,” Krueger noted.

Are “ETF Paper Bitcoin” Real?

These historical events have contributed to the current apprehension about ETFs and the possibility that they might be engaging in similar practices—selling Bitcoin they do not actually hold, thereby suppressing BTC’s price through artificial supply. However, Krueger argued that ETFs, particularly those managed by established financial institutions, operate under a fundamentally different framework compared to unregulated exchanges.

Focusing on two leading ETFs—IBIT, the BlackRock ETF, and FBTC, the Fidelity ETF—Krueger emphasized the stringent regulatory oversight governing these entities. “Both of these ETFs are subject to very strict regulatory oversight, including the SEC but also other agencies in the US,” he stated. This comprehensive oversight includes requirements for complete transparency, regular audits, and the use of third-party custodians for asset verification. “They literally have to get a receipt of an asset from a third-party custodian,” Krueger added.

In the case of IBIT, Coinbase serves as the third-party custodian. “Coinbase is itself a public company that is audited,” Krueger pointed out, noting that the public nature of Coinbase adds an additional layer of scrutiny and accountability. IBIT conducts audits of Coinbase, and both entities are subject to audits by the SEC and other regulatory bodies. For FBTC, custody is handled by Fidelity Digital Assets, a separate entity within Fidelity that specializes in the custody of digital assets, thereby ensuring specialized oversight and management.

“The issuers of IBIT and FBTC are BlackRock and Fidelity, two of the largest and oldest financial institutions, and they have a vested interest in maintaining their reputation,” Krueger asserted. “Their reputation is at stake, and this is a big deal,” he emphasized, suggesting that these institutions would not risk their credibility by engaging in the sale of non-existent Bitcoin.

Krueger contrasted BlackRock with entities like QuadrigaCX to underscore the disparity in regulatory compliance and operational scale. “BlackRock is highly regulated […] BlackRock has a robust corporate governance structure with committees for audit, risk, and compliance and very extensive internal controls,” Krueger added.

Addressing the core concern about ETFs holding “paper Bitcoin,” Krueger provided specific data to refute this notion. “The reality is the ETFs have zero pure paper Bitcoin,” he stated unequivocally. He highlighted that IBIT holds approximately 403,000 actual Bitcoins, while FBTC holds about 185,000 actual Bitcoins. “Together, these two ETFs hold almost 3% of the world’s total Bitcoin, or 588,000 Bitcoins—I think it’s 2.9%,” he calculated.

Krueger acknowledged that some skeptics have attempted to analyze Bitcoin movement between specific dates to challenge these holdings. However, he emphasized that the facts are clear and verifiable. “We know how much Bitcoin these ETFs have; we know that it’s accounted for, and that’s a reality,” he insisted.

Turning to the question of why Bitcoin’s price has not increased more dramatically despite significant ETF inflows, Krueger offered a nuanced explanation. He noted that Bitcoin is, in fact, up by 60% since the introduction of the ETFs, translating to a $600 billion increase in market capitalization. This growth has been fueled by approximately $20 billion in net inflows into the ETFs, resulting in a price multiplier effect of about 30x. “That’s historically about normal, maybe a little on the low side but not terribly so,” he assessed.

Krueger attributed the moderation in Bitcoin’s price growth to substantial selling pressures from various sources. “There’s been a bunch of selling,” he explained. He detailed that Germany sold $3 billion worth of Bitcoin as well as Mt. Gox holdings. Additionally, FTX sold its GBTC (Grayscale Bitcoin Trust) stake earlier in the year, and the Digital Currency Group (DCG) sold assets to resolve lawsuits. “We had a lot of selling,” Krueger summarized.

Speculating on the potential impact absent these selling pressures, Krueger suggested that Bitcoin’s price could have been significantly higher. “We probably would be at $90k if there wasn’t any selling,” he posited.

At press time, BTC traded at $68,752.

Bitcoin price

Latest Press

post-thumbnail
News
3 hours ago
WhaleAlert Notes 200M DOGE Transfer, DOGE Rises Over 20%
The post WhaleAlert Notes 200M DOGE Transfer, DOGE Rises Over 20% appeared first on Coinpedia Fintec...
READ MORE
post-thumbnail
News
3 hours ago
Pendle Team Moves Over 2M Tokens Worth $11M to Binance
The post Pendle Team Moves Over 2M Tokens Worth $11M to Binance appeared first on Coinpedia Fintech ...
READ MORE
post-thumbnail
News
3 hours ago
Breaking: Bitcoin Reaches A New ATH Of $80K! More Room To Rise Further?
The post Breaking: Bitcoin Reaches A New ATH Of $80K! More Room To Rise Further? appeared first on C...
READ MORE
default post thumbnail
News
3 hours ago
Avalanche Nears Breakout – Top Analyst Sets $420 Target For AVAX This Cycle
Avalanche (AVAX) has surged over 40%, reaching a critical supply level that, if broken, could trigge...
READ MORE
post-thumbnail
News
3 hours ago
$1,400 On The Horizon? Solana Breach Of $200 Excites Analysts
Solana, the leading Layer 1 blockchain platform, has at last overcome the critical $200 barrier, giv...
READ MORE
default post thumbnail
News
3 hours ago
Dogecoin Price Hits New 2024 High: Here Are 2 Ways It Could Go From Here
The Dogecoin price action since the beginning of the week has been nothing short of impressive. Nota...
READ MORE
default post thumbnail
News
3 hours ago
Donald Trump Plans ‘Crypto Recovery Act’ – Here Are the Top Coins to Buy Now
Speculation is mounting that Donald Trump is preparing to unveil a major initiative to stimulate the...
READ MORE
default post thumbnail
News
3 hours ago
Analyst Reveals Bitcoin Key Support Levels For Reaccumulation – Details
The price of Bitcoin showed a highly positive reaction to Donald Trump’s emergence as the next US ...
READ MORE
default post thumbnail
News
3 hours ago
Ethereum’s Market Cap Lags $1 Trillion Behind Bitcoin (BTC): Here’s When ETH Will Catch Up?
As of 5 November 2024, Bitcoin has not only managed to maintain its status but has also expanded its...
READ MORE
default post thumbnail
News
3 hours ago
SUI Network Launches SnoozeCat: The Next Big Meme Coin Amidst Bull Run
SnoozeCat is here to wake up your crypto potential! Join our presale and Game Airdrop for exclusive ...
READ MORE

Publish an article now

Unlock the power of media for instant visibility to the target audience, major SEO boost, greater website traffic and conversion rates.

click here to get started